PDD-24-7758

Every appearance2 of 2 are in a recording

TranscriptWhat was said at each appearance is below it. Machine transcription, with speaker names inferred from voice matching. 94% of 68 lines carry a name. It shows what was said, not what was decided, and both the words and the names can be wrong.

1. 1Jan 4, 2024
   Planning CommissionP12Consent agendaNo disposition in the minutes

   Open this item →▶ Play from 34:17
   ▶ 34:179m

   Charles GreyChair

   34:17Okay, I think we got one more. Uh trouble. We got trouble coming now.

   Liam Devine

   34:22Troublemaker, huh?

   Charles GreyChair

   34:23Yeah.

   Liam Devine

   34:27Liam Devine planning developing. Happy New Year's. Um this is item P12. Before I begin, I do want to note that there was an update to attachment nine. That was for the affidavit. It was not notarized. A notarized copy has been sent to the clerk's office.

   34:42Um item P D D 24-7758 in the name of Carlton E. and Elise Ellison. It is the Euclidean zoning amendment from AR Agricultural Residential District. To C2 General Commercial District with a future land use classification of COM Commercial under the comprehensive plan. There was a Comp Plan amendment back in August, August 8th of 2023, of that change from REST 6 to COM Commercial. The proposal is to develop the property

   35:12with a maximum of 110,000 square feet self-storage facility in conformance with the C2 General Commercial District standards. And the subject site is located on the south side of Curley Road, approximately 850 feet northeast of the intersection of Curley Road and State Road 54.

   35:29The subject site is located in the South Market area and is located in the urban service area and is outside of the rural areas.

   35:40Here is a context map of some of the MPUDs in the area, and then BOPH, which is that blue in the top right.

   35:53Here's an aerial view.

   35:56Here is a closer aerial view.

   36:01The surrounding future land use to the northeast and south is all Res 6. To the west is Com Commercial and Res 6. The surrounding zoning to the north is AR and MPUD. It's of the Pine Ridge M Pud. To the east is AC, to the south is AR, and to the west is AR. The subject site consists of a single family dwelling in approximately 4.423 acres. On October 17, 2023, the applicant held a neighborhood meeting, and this is coming with a voluntary agreed-upon deed restriction as

   36:31provided in your agenda packet. And this is coming with a recommendation of approval from P D D staff. Do you have any questions?

   Charles GreyChair

   36:43Any questions? Okay. All right. Is the applicant present?

   36:54Shame on here to object.

   Applicant's Attorney

   36:56Sorry.

   Charles GreyChair

   36:57I was asking if there's anyone here to object to anything or to speak. Okay.

   Applicant's Attorney

   37:02Uh and uh for the record Kevin Ray Alley 401 East Jackson Street in Tampa and to the Chairman's question, um we we have a presentation prepared and we asked for some more time. Um uh but in the absence of opposition here if there's no one online, uh we're really just there to answer questions. Um the history here as to why there were questions is if you all remember um the future land use application change for this property included property to the west and there were subsequent um uh app not

   37:32applications but uh submissions to staff for pre-apps and things to develop that with a more intense use. Uh we had our neighborhood meeting we explained that this is this is not what that is. This is just a portion of that future land use map change. So with the pleasure of the commission we have a presentation but um otherwise if if there are no questions we'll we'll just um stand by.

   Charles GreyChair

   37:52Okay. Any questions? Okay, if not then uh

   Pasco County

   37:58So Liam, this was on regular because of what happened with the future land use amendment, not because of

   Liam Devine

   38:05Yeah, no, this was unregular is because staff received a letter of opposition that usually triggers us to put an item on regular that was provided in your agenda packet and is one of your towns.

   38:18Sure. Yeah, tell me.

   Charles GreyChair

   38:23What's the substance of the letter to Liam Binett? Can you just summarize it quickly?

   Liam Devine

   38:29Ooh, I don't have the letter in front of me, um, so I don't want to misquote it. Um but if you give me a second I can pull it up and we can refresh my memory and I could write that.

   Denise

   38:39I have it here.

   38:42Writing to you as a concerned resident, I live in the Pine Ridge community. It's increased traffic on Curly Road. The traffic uses Curly Road is predominantly residential. This property is directly behind my home. It's going to impact my property value. There's going to be noise behind my house. The area still consist of trees and nature. Nobody wants a view from their home of a storage building. There's already a storage facility across the street on 54.

   39:14I'm concerned about the impact on my privacy. as a result of people exiting the site and we they don't see how there's a viable need for another storage unit.

   Jon Moody

   39:31Okay.

   Charles GreyChair

   39:35All right. Anything from uh DIES?

   Jaimie GirardiVice Chair

   39:39Uh just a comment because this recently happened in my neighborhood with a climate controlled self storage.

   39:49Please don't cut off a neighborhood's access to provide a a directionalized access into a climate controlled storage. That's what happened to my neighborhood. And unfortunately that's a decision of the Florida D. O. T. and the F and F D. O. T. isn't for Florida at this time, but Um, we really didn't appreciate that. We can't make a left turn out of our neighborhood so that a climate control can have its own channelized

   40:19access, left turn in for all of the the whole purpose of these things and then of this is that you know, it's gonna generate less than fifty peak hour driveway trip, so I'm not understanding why a climate controlled storage would need its own access at the expense of a neighborhood's access. But I hope that doesn't happen here. Just to comment. I'm not opposed to this project.

   Charles GreyChair

   40:44Okay.

   Jon Moody

   40:44Anything else? What kind of um uh is there any um plans for buffering or any kind of um uh site uh sight line abatement or what's what's the you know what w do you have a kind of c concept plan for So um

   Applicant's Attorney

   41:04we we do have a concept plan. I don't know if we have a printed

   41:06out

   41:07though, Cynthia. Do you have a printout? So the the code already requires a pretty significant setback and the FAR is relatively low at point six, so it's only gonna be uh a two-story facility. And so the combination of the setback and the the limited height uh we think is a is uh a significant buffer and there's gonna be a buffer requirement in the code uh along curly road. Uh additionally the the opposition letter we checked the dates on that and that was the same date of our of our neighborhood meeting and given that the that um that uh person isn't here

   41:37today when we talked through all of these things a lot of the conversation at that meeting had to do with um like I said the the use uh that was uh in for a pre app to the to the West Um and then the other questions were you know will it be Windows. The club requires windows but the the facility will likely have um uh like a glossing on the windows because that's more for for architectural look than it is for function. Um another concern was hours. This is not gonna be a 247 facility.

   42:07It will close in the night. Um so it's low traffic generating, low noise, uh low impact to that respect. And there were questions about drainage, but the the topography of the site is such that it actually flows away from the neighborhood. So the site will have a swift microfire Of course, but additionally it would flow uh away from the neighborhood anyway, uh even without that type of improvement. So those are the things that we addressed at the meeting and I I'm I'm taking from uh that person not being here today that the meeting satisfied their questions. I can't speak for them, but that's you know that's for the Commissioner decide. Okay. All

   42:37right. What's up? Yeah, I talked about it, yeah.

   Jon Moody

   42:43Okay. Any other questions?

   42:47And the deed restriction is uh regarding uh live local

   Applicant's Attorney

   42:52Live Local and um trip cap because of the uh time uh exemption from timing and phasing.

   Jaimie GirardiVice Chair

   42:58Okay.

   Applicant's Attorney

   43:00'Cause it uh you know, as stated, this is a low traffic generator.

   Charles GreyChair

   43:05Okay, banger emotionally.

   Chris Williams

   43:11I'll make the motion to approve.

   Jaimie GirardiVice Chair

   43:13I'll second it.

   Charles GreyChair

   43:14Have a motion and second. Any further discussion of the motion? If not, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Aye. Opposed, like signed. Okay. Motion carried.

2. 2Feb 6, 2024
   Board of County CommissionersP49Public hearingApproved

   Approved minutes

   Approved Staff’s recommendation including the submitted corrections on the Agenda

   Open this item →▶ Play from 41:51
   ▶ 41:513m

   Unidentified speakerVoice A

   41:51Okay. P forty-nine was advertised in the Tampa Bay Times December 20th, 2023, and by affidavit of certified mailings and site postings.

   Denise

   42:00Good afternoon, Commissioner Starkey Hernandez Planning and Development. Item P49 is PDD 247758, which is a zoning amendment in the name of Carlton E. and Elise V. Ellison Trust. It's for a change in zoning from an AR agricultural residential district to a C2 General Commercial District with a voluntarily agreed upon deed restriction, which uh there are some corrections that have been made to the record. Those have already been provided to the clerk. Office. That includes striking the following in finding a fact number one, the

   42:31phrase maximum of 110,000 square feet or square foot. Also striking in the voluntarily agreed upon deed restriction, the term which would include but not be limited to 110,000 square feet of self-storage. Those corrections have been made on both the agenda memo, the resolution, and the deed restriction. The voluntarily agreed upon deed restriction is to basically limit the uses to those C2 uses.

   43:01That generate less than 50 peak hour trips, AM or PM, whichever is higher, and also to provide the live local deed restriction, which is reserving those uses for specifically for C2 uses, comes to you with a recommendation of approval from the Planning and Development Department and from the Planning Commission who heard the item on January 4th, 2024. More.

   Ron OakleyChair

   43:27Okay. Uh is anyone signed up to speak against the side?

   Unidentified speakerVoice A

   43:31No, sir. And not on

   Ron OakleyChair

   43:31WebAssembly. Okay. No one here to speak. Anyone in the audience wish to speak to this item? So you know one move approval?

   Kathryn Starkey

   43:41Second.

   Ron OakleyChair

   43:42Yeah. Got a motion and a second. All those in favor by roll call vote.

   Unidentified speakerVoice A

   43:46District two, Commissioner Weightman. Bye. Was that nay, sir? Okay.

   Seth Weightman

   43:54No, it was it was aye.

   Unidentified speakerVoice A

   43:56Okay. Thank you. Thank you for the clarification. It's important. District three, Commissioner Starkey. Aye. District four, Commissioner Bradford. Aye. District five, Commissioner Mariano? Aye. District one, Chairman Oakley.

   Ron OakleyChair

   44:08Aye. Motion pass 5-0. That's the end of the public hearing. And we will uh

   Seth Weightman

   44:15Chairman

   Ron OakleyChair

   44:15Mari

   Seth Weightman

   44:17Carol, thank you. I just want to make the comment to P49. Uh the folks that we can get for P49, I just want to say I appreciate them taking the amount of time they've been talking.

   44:51limited on its height uh and the footprint of it and it'll kind of sneak right sneak right by it. So this is just a an example of uh where storage probably should go. And uh

   45:11So

   Ron OakleyChair

   45:12Yeah, thank you.