Anonymous code enforcement complaints
What the county recorded
This item is not from the published agenda
It is a stretch of the recording that this archive identified as a separate matter — a call to order, a recess, or something taken up that the agenda does not list. There is no official title, no staff recommendation and no disposition, because the county never recorded one. Everything below is inferred.
The source document
The county’s agenda for Board of County Commissioners, Dec 16, 2024
The published PDF. Its text could not be extracted — it is an image-only scan — so nothing in it is searchable here, but it reads normally.
The county’s minutes for Board of County Commissioners, Dec 16, 2024
The published PDF, as served by the county. This item is one entry in it.
What was said
Machine transcription of 5m of recording, with speaker names inferred from voice matching. 77% of 22 lines carry a name. It shows what was said, not what was decided, and both the words and the names can be wrong.
Okay, the uh next issue also part of the uh FAC agenda. Um you'll remember back in 21 the law was changed, but before 2021, code enforcement complaints could be made by residents anonymously. Uh now it requires them to put their name in. We try to go around that uh when the bill was created and allow the residents to call their county commissioner so they could put that in. Um we
we did that uh uh we have been doing that uh a lot, but Just not enough manpower to go around the county. So it would be good if we can get that back in and repeal that law. Uh you'll remember this is uh snitches get stitches law that passed in twenty uh one. Um
That is the truth.
We actually had a resident. You had a resident. I think this is something near and dear to you, but we had a resident that was uh attacked. Yes
by his name. He had a house that had drug dealing and other things going on next to him and called it in and they beat him up and he got his his face was all cut up and was in the hospital and stitches all over his face. Um so when we brought this up at FAC Every county came forward with horror stories. of of uh what's going on when when um you make some of these calls and and the the person comes in and does something to their property or to
them physically. I do think there there needs to be some kind of guardrails because I know I think the reason it switched when we had a legislator from South Florida was that s some people use it um a as a way to antagonize a neighbor or something. So You know, maybe so many calls on one address. Um I'm sure code enforcement could or someone could come up with the right guardrails, but there does need to be guardrails, but we we have a a lot of citizens who are now afraid to call in
and um it's really impacted a lot of neighborhoods across the state.
Like a lot of things that happen in the legislature, uh actions that occur in Miami Dade, Brower County, Long Beach County, uh affect all of us statewide because Rebuilt the ro wall in the wrong part of the United States and um should be should be that part.
We need South Florida Blaws and the rest of the same Florida.
I would be shocked if we changed it back to anonymous but guardrails. Maybe our consideration. And I'm assuming Bay is looking for some sponsor.
One of the guards we talked about is keeping it for twelve months quick and then releasing it twelve month
Ralph Shum's gonna need a mic. Oh yeah.
So the the association has also talked about proposing a guardrail to keep it private for twelve months and then releasing it. One, you know that you uh made that call, that that information would be available in twelve months, so that could be a guardrail they could consider.
Yeah, something may work. is to allow an HOA to put a complaint and that's what we used to do a lot. That worked very well. Because now it doesn't attach even a person, but it knows a group that's going out there. Sometimes we don't have HOAs but we have other citizen groups that are there offici official in in like Crime Watch, et cetera, they can see it as well. But any anything to get it reported where someone doesn't get that retribution. I and I've got a couple where people got beat up really bad. Yeah
as well. And it's just
it's like Putting neighbor against neighbor just doesn't build good relations anyway. But The the bottom line is if the police can take an arm complaint, why can't we have code of course we do the same thing?
I I'm I'm talking unanimous support from all the counties that pass.
Uh Commissioner when you say like an HOA would put the complaint, so if somebody looked it up they would just see H O A H O A
exactly complaint. But you know, for me m a lot of my district on holiday there there are no HOAs. Um and we're working so hard to clean that up and this has been a real step backwards for those kind of neighborhoods.
That's what's that's why I say cr Crime Watch Group. Like Nancy Bonita's Gulf Islands very organized, they meet once a month. They they could do it as well the same way.
And there's areas in every county including this one where code enforcement is an ongoing Daily right. Yes, what it is, yeah.
So I I I think it's a valid valid consideration.